  Pickleville's COVID-19 Plans & Policies
New Sheriff in Town

A Rip-Roarin' Whodunit Original

About This Show

From the creators of our 2021 smash hit, Becoming A Bona Fide Bad Guy, Pickleville proudly presents our brand-new, rip-roarin’, modern musical melodrama: New Sheriff in Town! When the local sheriff passes away, town deputy, Will Bailey, assumes he’s next in line for the job. Much to Will's surprise, state officials send in Roy Wrangler, a hot shot, fast-talking, out-of-town Sheriff to fill the position.

Immediate chaos ensues with a robbery at the Wet Whistle Saloon. The only problem: nobody knows who did it. The plot thickens as we follow our unlikely law enforcement duo down a winding whodunit, filled with loads of fresh music, a barrel of belly laughs, and a plot-twist that will leave you gasping for days! Get your tickets now — this hysterical and heartfelt production is sure to be the highlight of your family’s summer!


1 hour 45 min
w/ 15 min intermission


H (for Hilarious)


May 27 - Sept 5

Created By:

Derek Davis

Reviews from our Patrons
Reviews will be posted Soon!
We'll update this section as soon as the show starts.

"This show was AWESOME & HILARIOUS! We will be going again and taking more people with us!"

Instagram User

"Absolutely hilarious! Numerous plot twists! Top notch performers!"

Instagram User

"Oh. My. Goodness. We laughed our guts out! I was crying. Just SOOO good!"

Instagram user

"Amazingly FUN!"

Instagram user

Who's in the Cast?
Paige Michaels
Piano (Thick As Thieves)
Paige Michaels
Piano (Thick as Thieves)
James Farmer
Piano (Thick as Thieves)
Jaylen T Bryant
Sebastian (The Little Mermaid)
Grace Heinz
Audio Engineer
Camille Chandler
Audio Engineer
Peyton Davis
Stage Manager (Thick as Thieves)
Taylor Hall
Jim (Thick as Thieves), Grimsby (The Little Mermaid)
Parker Beus
King Triton (The Little Mermaid)
Kenzie Davis Kremin
Director (The Little Mermaid)
Griffin Welti
Jim (Thick as Thieves), Jetsam/Chef Louis (The Little Mermaid)
Annika Erickson
Becky (Thick as Thieves), Mersister (The Little Mermaid)
Kaylee Rasmussen
Light Board Operator (Thick as Thieves), Stage Manager (The Little Mermaid)
Logan Kelley
Music Director (Thick as Thieves)
Nick Crapo
Roger (Thick as Thieves), Scuttle (The Little Mermaid)
Dean Bressler
Lighting Designer
Hannah Bonnette
Alexa (Thick as Thieves), Mersister (The Little Mermaid)
Nathan Kremin
Hamm (Thick as Thieves)
Rylee Carpenter
Becky (Thick As Thieves), Ariel (The Little Mermaid)
Katja Roberts
Alexa (Thick as Thieves), Mersister (The Little Mermaid)
Jaycee Harris
Brisket (Thick As Thieves), Mersister (The Little Mermaid)
Will Mosier
Roger (Thick as Thieves), Prince Eric (The Little Mermaid)
Alec Foote
Flotsam (The Little Mermaid)
Peyton Davis
Flounder (The Little Mermaid)
Lilli Rowan
Light Board Operator
Justine Grace
Brisket (Thick as Thieves), Mersister (The Little Mermaid)
Devin Davis
Ursula (The Little Mermaid)
Bodie (bad Guy)
Kyle Purbaugh
Music Production (Thick As Thieves)
Jordan Todd Brown
Script Advisor (Thick as Thieves)
TJ Davis
Music Director (The Little Mermaid)
Andrea Davis
Sharli Davis King
Choreographer (Thick as Thieves)
Whitley Osborn Davis
Costumer Designer, Choreographer (The Little Mermaid)
Derek Davis
Writer/Director (Thick as Thieves)
Bodie Brower
Graphic/Website Design, Video, Photo

Learn about our other exciting productions:

SUMMER • June 13 - Aug 23
Other things to do at Pickleville
2022 Auditions
Auditions will be starting February 1st for our exciting 2022 season. Get the lasted info by following us on social media or sign up for email updates below!
Thick As Thieves
Playing May 26 - Sept 4
The Little Mermaid
Playing June 20 - Aug 18
Pickleville Grill
Serving deliciousness each evening between shows starting May 26th.
Pickleville Camp
Join us for a full week of: singing, dancing, acting, and HAVING A BLAST!
The Addams Family
Playing Sept 30 - Oct 22
Enchanted Stories with Belle
Come enjoy an enchanted story time for your kids and a photo op with Belle and her friends.
Get notified of special offers and updates including upcoming shows and added performances!
© 2023 Pickleville Playhouse
All Awesomeness Reserved  •